The Milburn report - key headlines
Alex Morris & Alex Evans
Almost one in eight young people in the UK are not earning or learning. Yesterday’s Milburn Review sets out how to change that, and it’s a moment the skills and education sector should pay attention to.
The UK has almost 1m people aged 16 to 24 who are not in education, employment, or training – this is a rate of c13%. These young people are known as NEETs, and only one country across Europe has a higher rate than the UK. The rate has barely dipped below 10% in the last 25 years.
The impact of being NEET lasts. The report estimates that a young person who spends six years NEET could lose up to c£300k in lifetime earnings, even after they return to work.
Behind those numbers, Milburn sees a “whole system failure”: the labour market has turned against young people, education isn’t preparing them for work, health services react too late, welfare traps rather than springboards, and no joined-up system exists to support them.
Without change, Milburn warns, the crisis will only grow. The report’s key recommendations include:
- Overhaul the benefit system to scrap Universal Credit for under-25s in favour of a Youth Allowance and replace PIP with two targeted funds.
- Lift employers’ National Insurance thresholds from £5k to £10k for 21- to 24-year-olds in retail and hospitality.
- Double apprenticeship completions by 2036, so they “rival university as a mainstream destination”.
- Expand post-18 education with 150k more college places, plus new employer-led technical colleges driven by regional mayors.
- Pay employers to hire NEETs, providing £3k for taking on someone inactive for six months, or £2k if they’ve been in care or are disabled.
Beyond the headlines, two themes stood out to us, and both come back to one thing: work is changing faster than the systems that prepare people for it.
- Starting early. Milburn writes that “the world of work is changing faster than the world of education.” He wants schools to build aptitudes, not just knowledge, judged against a new ready-for-work standard. Across the sector, approaches to qualification development, learning design, and teaching built for a previous world must be reinvented at the same pace.
- Keeping the first rung. The report finds the first rung of the career ladder has eroded, with AI reshaping work faster than ever. Its proposed Youth Opportunity Service will make it easier for employers to offer first chances. But employers can go further: by upskilling the people they already employ, they open up progression that frees up entry-level roles.
These recommendations will land on awarding organisations, colleges, training providers, professional bodies, mayors and local leaders. Each will need to rethink how skills are defined, assessed, and recognised, and build new routes into work, often at pace.
The review is a substantial piece of policy work, which has rightly, and helpfully, cut through to the front page in a way that education and training matters too often do not. As Government considers its response to the review, we have questions.
- Milburn's proposed AI Youth Observatory is an interesting proposal in a review which is otherwise surprisingly light on the implications of AI for young people and their careers. What will the implications of scaled AI adoption be for the labour market, and how can we mitigate the obvious downside risks for young people…?
- Milburn is right to castigate the UK's inability to shift the dial on NEETs. But youth employment levels are at least in part a function of wider economic performance. Growth, productivity, and leadership and management are longstanding issues upstream. How impactful can Milburn’s recommendations be without wider, demand-side, progress…?
We’ll be discussing the review, colleagues’ and Government’s response to it, next week.